Wednesday, August 29, 2007

Electoral Politics & the New York Times on National Review Online

Matthew J. Franck takes on the New York Times and the issue of the California electoral vote allocation.
The district-tally system proposed in California is also hard to assess for its impact on the two-party system. To have much of an impact, a minor-party candidate would have to roll up some House districts, and that won’t soon happen. But eventually the decay of the two-party system might set in, and for some people, myself included, that’s reason enough to oppose the California initiative.

But this argument requires some thought, not just a knee-jerk fear that one’s favored party will be disadvantaged in the near term. And that’s all the Times had to offer.

No comments: